Well, if Clay Buchholz will refuse to return to the lineup, the Red Sox have been put in a position to, in essence, replace him.
With Will Middlebrooks waiting in the wings, Sox have been put in a position to get rid of current third basemen Jose Iglecias.
They did both of those things last night as the Red Sox, Tigers and White Sox organized a mega 7 player, 3 team deal that would put Iglecias in a Tigers uniform, White Sox star: Jake Peavy in Boston and 5 other players distributed through Detroit and Chicago.
But nevertheless, when one looks at this trade some questions arise. In 63 games with the Sox, Jose Iglecias had come to bat 215 times, putting up 71 hits and handing himself a batting average of .330. Iglacias was dominant, wielding his stellar glove like a weapon and batting over .400 for each of the first 43 games he played. Looking ahead, Iglecias showed promise and represented a breath of youth into a ageing Red Sox lineup. But nevertheless, here we are, talking about the day that Jose Iglacias has been traded away.
So... if we all like Iglecias this much who is Boston getting in return? They are getting a 32 year old righty with the imminent possibility of ousting Lester, Lackey or Buchholz and becoming Boston's number one pitcher.
After making in MLB debut in 2002, the then Padres rookie compiled an acceptable start in the league going 6-7 in that 02 season. At that point in time, Peavy seemed to be the pitcher of the future and a guy who could easily shoot up a 20 win season in coming years. But by 2009, the Padres had made the playoffs just twice and despite the regular season contributions of their praised pitcher, they had never made it out of the 1st round. A change was badly needed.
By 2010, Peavy was a White Sox and in the coming years, despite being riddled with inguries, he put up formidable numbers. In 3 years, Peavy won 36 games with Chicago.
Yet after so many years of pitching success, here he is, Jake Peavy has changed his Sox and in the words of GM Ben Cherrington, "We're really excited to bring Jake in here," said Cherington, who noted that Red Sox special assignment scout Mark Wasinger was the scout who originally signed Peavy to a big league contract after he was drafted in the 15th round by San Diego in 1999. "He's obviously a proven major league starter with a ton of success in his career. The one thing we wanted to do, if we could pull it off, when we looked at the next two months, we're in a position to compete for a playoff spot, and adding a starting pitcher was the most important thing we could do to add to that."
Now embedded within those quoted lines lies another huge question: once Buchholz comes back (and he will) what do you do with what now seems to be a three way battle for the title of starting ace. As it stands, you have Boston's win leader: Jon Lester with his resurgent 10 and 6 win loss record. Then you have Mr ERA in John Lackey with his average of just 3.19 runs per game... and last but not least there is Buchholz. Now he does not lead in any of Boston’s major pitching categories, he has been out of the lineup for over 2 months now. But he has chucked 12 games of action and while his record states that he had only been credited with 9 wins, Buchholz has started 11 Boston victories and only seen his team loose once when he began the night on the hill. Trough those first few months of the year, Clay Buchholz was a prime candidate for not only an all-star game appearance (an achievement he did reach despite his injury) but also a Cy Young victory.
So, Buchholz, Lackey, Lester and now Jake Peavy?! 4 star starters and no definitive name that reigns supreme...but is that necessarily a bad thing?
2 years ago when the Sox suffered their terrifying September collapse, the Sox top 4 pitchers were clearly defined. Beckett was one, Jon Lester was number 2, Diceke Matsuzaka was number 3, and Tim Wakefeild was 4. Yet look what happened then. 2 seasons later, what is wrong with a little competition, it drives guys to compete with one another and it means that instead of partying, and drinking in the clubhouse they are striving to incense their fitness and simply win games.
Buchholz can play, Lester can play, Lackey can play, and heck, if Jake Peavy can too, that that might be all it takes to climb onto a level playing field with Tampa and turn this pending pennant race into one for the ages.